How to Minimize Taxes on Stock Options: 5 Best Strategies

10.5 MIN READ

Stock options are a great way to build wealth, but they can come with hefty tax bills. If you're not careful, a large chunk of your earnings could go straight to the IRS. This is why it's important to learn how to minimize taxes on stock options.

Unfortunately, many people don't fully understand how stock options are taxed. You might think you're making smart financial moves, only to have an unexpected tax bill that eats into your profits.

Things can also get complicated quickly between the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT), ordinary income tax, and capital gains tax. This guide will break down the best ways to minimize your tax burden so you can keep more of your hard-earned money.

What Are Stock Options?

Stock options are a type of payment where your company gives you the right to buy their stock at a set price, called the exercise price or strike price.

This price stays the same even if the company's stock value goes up. If the stock price rises above your exercise price, you can buy shares cheaper than what they're worth and make money from the difference.

However, the way you exercise and sell your options affects how much tax you owe.

There are two primary types of stock options, each with its own tax rules:

Incentive Stock Options (ISOs): These are available to employees as part of a compensation package. They come with tax benefits, such as the potential to be taxed at the lower capital gains rate instead of as ordinary income. However, ISOs are subject to the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) if improperly handled.
Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs): Unlike ISOs, NSOs do not receive favorable tax treatment. When exercised, the difference between the market and exercise prices is taxed as ordinary income, which can push you into a higher tax bracket.

The right tax strategy depends on which type of options you have, your financial situation, and your investment goals.

Equity Compensation Types

Stock options are just one form of equity compensation. Understanding all types helps you see how options fit into the bigger picture.

Incentive Stock Options (ISOs)

ISOs often offer the best potential tax advantages of any equity compensation. Only employees can receive ISOs, and they must follow specific IRS rules to get the tax benefits.

Key features of ISOs include:

No tax at grant
No regular income tax at exercise (but may trigger AMT)
If held long enough (1 year after exercise AND 2 years after grant), profits are taxed at lower long-term capital gains rates
$100,000 limit on options that can become exercisable in any calendar year

The potential for favorable tax treatment makes ISOs valuable, but you need careful planning to avoid a surprising Alternative Minimum Tax bill from the IRS.

Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs)

NSOs are more flexible than ISOs. Companies can grant them to anyone – employees, contractors, directors, or advisors.

Key features of NSOs include:

No tax at grant
Taxed as ordinary income at exercise on the "spread" (difference between market price and exercise price)
Subject to payroll taxes (Social Security and Medicare) at exercise
Any additional gain after exercise is taxed as capital gain when shares are sold

NSOs don't offer preferential tax treatment like ISOs, but they provide more flexibility for companies and create fewer tax complications for employees managing their tax liability.

RSUs

RSUs are not options but actual shares of company stock given to you after meeting vesting requirements.

Key features of RSUs include:

No tax at grant
Taxed as ordinary income at vesting on the full value of shares received
No choice about when to pay taxes (unlike options)
Simpler tax treatment than options
Popular at larger public companies

RSUs eliminate the need to decide when to exercise, but you'll pay ordinary income tax rates on the fair market value of the stock at vesting, which impacts your overall tax obligation.

Related Article | How to Avoid Double Taxation on RSU Sales

How Are Stock Options Taxed?

Two key events influence taxes on stock options: exercise and sale.

Exercise Event

When you exercise stock options, you buy shares of the underlying stock at your strike price (also called exercise price). The tax consequences depend on what type of options you have.

For ISOs:

Exercising ISOs doesn't trigger regular income tax. However, the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) can create unexpected tax bills if you're not prepared.

The difference between the fair market value and your exercise price is called the "bargain element" or "spread." This spread is not taxable for regular income tax purposes.

However, this spread is an adjustment for Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) purposes. Many people face a substantial tax obligation from AMT when exercising ISOs without selling.

For NSOs:

Non-Qualified Stock Options create an immediate tax hit at exercise. The IRS treats the discount you received as ordinary income, just like your salary.

The spread (fair market value minus exercise price) is taxed immediately as ordinary income. This appears on your W-2 if you're an employee, increasing your taxable income.

You'll pay income tax at your ordinary income tax rates, and you're also subject to payroll taxes (Social Security and Medicare) on this amount. Your employer will typically withhold taxes from your paycheck or require you to pay them directly.

Sale Event

When you sell shares acquired through stock options, you'll face additional taxes based on how long you've held them.

For ISOs:

If you hold ISO shares for more than a year after exercise AND at least two years from the grant date, you've made a qualifying disposition. The entire gain above your exercise price is treated as long-term capital gains, with tax rates much lower than ordinary income tax rates. This is the most tax-efficient outcome for ISOs.

If you sell before meeting both holding periods, you've made a disqualifying disposition. The spread at exercise is taxed as ordinary income, and any additional gain or loss is taxed as capital gain (short-term or long-term).

For NSOs:

If you sell NSO shares within a year of exercise (short-term holding), you pay short-term capital gains tax on any appreciation since exercise. These rates are the same as ordinary income tax rates, which can be as high as 37% federal.

But if you hold for more than a year (long-term holding), you pay capital gains tax on any appreciation since exercise. This is typically 15% or 20%, depending on your income level.

How to Minimize Taxes on Stock Options: 5 Best Strategies

1. Strategic Exercise Timing

When you exercise your options matters for your tax bill.

For NSOs, exercise when your income is lower to reduce the tax hit on the spread. This could be during a sabbatical, after retirement, or in a year with fewer bonuses. For ISOs, exercising early in the calendar year gives you more time to evaluate whether to sell shares before year-end to avoid AMT.

You can also spread out your exercises over several years. This prevents a single large exercise from pushing you into higher tax brackets or triggering large AMT bills.

2. Hold ISOs for Qualifying Disposition

The biggest tax advantage of ISOs is the qualifying disposition. Hold ISO shares for at least one year after exercise and two years after grant, and your entire gain gets taxed at long-term capital gains rates (15-20%) instead of ordinary income rates (up to 37%).

At the same time, holding company stock for tax purposes means keeping more of your money tied to one company. If the stock price drops during your holding period, the tax savings might not be worth the investment loss.

3. Manage Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) Exposure

The AMT can create surprise tax bills when exercising ISOs. When you exercise ISOs, the bargain element becomes an AMT adjustment even though you haven't actually received any cash.

To manage AMT exposure:

Work with a tax professional to calculate your potential AMT liability before exercising
Exercise fewer options or exercise gradually
Consider a December exercise and January sale strategy (exercise in December, sell in January of the following year)

Keep track of AMT credits generated when you pay AMT. These credits can offset regular income tax in future years. Many people eventually recover much of their AMT payments through these credits.

Related Article | How to Avoid ATM on Stock Options

4. Consider Early Exercise (If Available)

Some companies let you exercise stock options before they vest. This is common with startups.

With early exercise, you buy unvested shares at your strike price. Since there's typically little difference between the market value and strike price early on, there's minimal taxable income or AMT impact.

You must file an 83(b) election with the IRS within 30 days of exercise. This tells the IRS you're choosing to be taxed on the shares now rather than as they vest.

The main benefit is starting your holding period for long-term capital gains sooner. This works best with early-stage companies where the strike price is very low. But if you leave the company before vesting, you'll forfeit unvested shares and can't recover the taxes you paid, so there's also risk.

5. Implement a Diversification Strategy

Having too much company stock creates both investment risk and tax issues, so it's important to diversify. Sell some shares periodically to put into other investments.

For ISOs held long enough, you'll pay the lower capital gains tax rather than ordinary income tax. For NSOs held long-term, you'll also benefit from lower capital gains rates on any appreciation since exercise.

So, What Is the Best Strategy for Reducing Taxes on Stock Options?

Naturally, there is no one-size-fits-all approach to minimizing taxes on stock options. It's a complex topic that typically requires using a tax advisor or a financial advisor who knows a lot about taxes on stock options. You'll need to evaluate factors like your current income tax bracket and projected future income, the type of stock options you hold (ISOs vs NSOs), and your overall financial goals.

FAQs

How Much Tax Do You Pay on Stock Options?

The tax rate on stock options depends on many factors. For NSOs, you pay ordinary income tax on the spread when you exercise (up to 37% federal rate), plus payroll taxes, and any additional gain after exercise is taxed as capital gains. For ISOs, you may owe AMT on the spread at exercise, but if you hold the shares for a qualifying disposition, your profit is taxed at long-term capital gains rates (0%, 15%, or 20% depending on your income), while selling earlier converts some or all profit to ordinary income. You also may need to pay state taxes (watch out for high-tax states like California).

What Happens If I Don't Exercise My Stock Options?

If you don't exercise your stock options before they expire, they become worthless. If you leave your company, your exercise window may shrink to just 90 days after departure (though some companies now offer extended post-termination exercise periods of several years). Check your stock option agreement for specific expiration terms.

Do I Have to Pay Taxes When I Exercise Stock Options?

For NSOs, yes, you'll owe ordinary income tax and payroll taxes on the spread at exercise even if you don't sell the shares. For ISOs, you don't owe regular income tax at exercise, but you may have ATM liability if the spread is substantial.

Is It Better to Exercise an Option or Sell It?

Employee stock options typically can't be sold. They must be exercised to capture their value, with the real decision being whether to exercise and hold the shares (potentially for tax advantages with ISOs) or exercise and immediately sell (a "cashless exercise"). It's a choice you have to make for yourself based on factors like your belief in the company's future.

Are Stock Options Taxed As Ordinary Income?

NSOs are always partially taxed as ordinary income (the spread at exercise is treated as compensation income). ISOs can potentially avoid ordinary income treatment if you meet the holding requirements for a qualifying disposition (1+ year after exercise, 2+ years after grant), in which case all profit is taxed as long-term capital gains.

The Bottom Line

Stock options come with a relatively nuanced and complicated tax treatment. The best thing you can do is consult with a knowledgeable tax professional who'll help you come up with a strategy to minimize your tax burden. What works for your colleague might not be right for your situation, so make sure to get personalized advice.